9 Substitute for Caraway Seeds That Have More or Less the Same Flavors You Need for Your Dish

Looking for any substitute available for cumin seeds?

Because ‘You were in the middle of creating a main course.

And he wanted a bittersweet, nutty-flavored spice to satisfy your inner Gordon Ramsay.

Searching for that magic spice everywhere, you realize that you used cumin seeds last week to prepare your delicious dinner, rye bread goulash.

What will happen now?

You search the internet for all the cumin seed alternatives you can find.

Hey, stop dealing with long, useless results.

You are in the right place!

The following list is ‘what can I use instead of cumin seeds?’ is the ultimate solution to your query. (Substitute for Caraway Seeds)

9 Substitute for Caraway Seeds for a Similar Flavor

Depending on the type of food you want, you may ask what is the best cumin seed substitute. The answer is right here, in our guide!

For Biscuits or Bread: Dill, Anise seeds and Dried Thyme

For the Casserole or Curries: Fennel, Nigella and Cumin seeds

For Soups: Dill, Cumin and Coriander Seeds

For Pickles or Cabbage Dishes: Anise, Star Anise, and Coriander Seeds

Let’s learn more about how you can use each of the mentioned substitutes for cumin seeds. (Substitute for Caraway Seeds)

1. Fennel Seeds

Cumin Vs. Fennel is a hot debate in the spice world.

People always ask, ‘Are cumin seeds the same as fennel seeds?’ he asks.

Sure, they belong to the same family, but fennel has a strong licorice-like flavor compared to mildly flavored cumin.

Addendum: Did you know that fennel can also be used as a substitute for fenugreek seeds?

When can you use fennel seeds as a substitute for cumin seeds?
Use this in Italian, Indian or Middle Eastern recipes.

Fennel seeds are quite different from cumin seeds in terms of flavor. However, both have similar extracts and licorice notes, making it your primary substitute for cumin seeds. (Substitute for Caraway Seeds)

How to substitute fennel for caraway?

You can use an equal amount of fennel seeds instead of cumin, which means if your recipe says to add 1 teaspoon of cumin, you should use the same amount of fennel seeds. (Substitute for Caraway Seeds)

Suggested Dishes:

• Hungarian Goulash
• Irish Soda Bread

2. Anise Seeds (Aniseed)

There is no such competition as anise and fennel; What is a better alternative to cumin seeds? But if your food requires a strong taste and aroma, anise seeds should be your ultimate choice. (Substitute for Caraway Seeds)

Are caraway and anise the same?

The anise and cumin seed swap depends on the type of dish you’re preparing as they share a common licorice flavor, but the former can be quite hot and stronger.

The best alternative to use when baking bread or cookies.

Remember, it can be very potent if used in large quantities. (Substitute for Caraway Seeds)

How to use anise seed as a substitute for caraway?

Instead of cumin, you can use half as much aniseed, so if your recipe says to add 1 teaspoon of cumin, you should use ½ teaspoon of aniseed. (Substitute for Caraway Seeds)

Suggested Dishes:

• Roasted Pork
• Rye Bread

Bonus: You can also try sous vide corned beef.

3. Dill Seeds

If you don’t have cumin seeds to finish your recipe, but found dill seeds in your cupboard. Since both belong to the Apiaceae family, that’s all you need to get the same taste from your food. (Substitute for Caraway Seeds)

When can you use dill seeds as a caraway replacement?

Cumin and dill seeds share the same family, which explains their somewhat similar taste, namely the slightly bitter citrus scent.

Perfect for light meals, cream soups, sprouts and rye bread instead of dill seeds. (Substitute for Caraway Seeds)

How to substitute dill for caraway?

You can use the same amount of dill seeds for cumin, meaning that if your dish’s ingredients say one teaspoon of cumin, you should also use one teaspoon of dill seeds. (Substitute for Caraway Seeds)

Suggested Dishes:

• Vegetarian Cabbage Soup
• Sauerkraut

4. Nigella Seeds

Nigella seeds are among the ancient spices that have been widely used since ancient Egyptian times. It has a similar punch of cumin and pairs well with other seasonings in savory dishes. (Substitute for Caraway Seeds)

Why nigella seeds are a worthy replacement for caraway?

The distinctive flavor and aroma of cumin, thyme, onion and licorice make it a valuable substitute for cumin.

Pro-tip: Remember to toast the toasted black cumin seeds before using as a substitute for best results. (Substitute for Caraway Seeds)

How to use nigella seeds instead of caraway?

It has a slightly sharp, bitter and intense taste. Therefore, it is enough to use a pinch of black cumin seeds instead of cumin seeds to make your servings equally tasty and delicious.

Instead of black cumin seeds, stew, curry and Indian naan, rye naan etc. It is very suitable for delicious breads such as

Suggested Dishes:

• Spiced Roasted Chicken
• Indian Naan

5. Star Anise

Star anise has a unique taste and aroma, like caraway seeds. It is a versatile spice that, when used sparingly, adds a unique flavor to food.

What can you use if you don’t have caraway seeds?

Like fennel, anise, dill, and nigella seeds, star anise pods have the aroma and flavor of licorice, making it on our list of cumin seed substitutes.

How to substitute star anise for caraway?

It has a sweet but intense licorice flavor and can overshadow any other flavor of your dish. But if only a pinch is used, it can add a sweet and savory flavor to your serving.

Suggested Dishes:

• Simmered Chicken
• Beet Pickled Egg

6. Cumin Seeds

While cumin is a prominent spice in breads, meat dishes, and pickles, cumin can be added to sauces, stews, and curries, making it a viable option.

Tip: Use cumin seeds for cumin seeds and ground cumin for ground cumin.

Can you use cumin as a caraway seed replacement?

Cumin is a commonly used spice in South Asian and Indian dishes, while cumin is often added to German, Eastern, African, Asian or Central European dishes.

However,

They look similar and are often confused with the same spice.

Cumin seeds are hotter and the flavor can be quite strong for some dishes, but they can replace cumin seeds if you want to add a delicious flavor to the dish.

How to use cumin seeds in place of caraway?

You can use the same amount of cumin seeds instead of caraway seeds, which means if your dish ingredients list says to use 1 teaspoon of caraway, you should also add 1 teaspoon of cumin seeds.

Suggested Dishes:

• Cauliflower Soup with Cheese
• Boiled Egg Mushroom and Brown Rice Hash

Other Substitute for Caraway Seeds

Cumin seeds are packed with strong aromas that can be presented well with related spices and herbs such as fennel, anise, dill, nigella sativa, star anise, and cumin seeds.

But,

There may be similar spices and herbs in your kitchen cabinet that you didn’t know you could use instead of cumin.

1. Celery Seeds

Celery seeds can impart a rich cumin seed flavor in potatoes, carrots, German beet salad, coleslaw, and other foods.

Bonus: Prepare your salad dressing with the ready-made salad cutter bowl. Save time and effort! (Give it all to devour the last meal :p).

How to Substitute: Same amount of cumin for the same amount of celery seeds

Recommended Dishes:

• Sweet potato and pickle salad
• German Cabbage Salad

2. Dried Oregano

If your food demands an intensely spicy taste with a delicious pepper flavor, dried thyme may be your optional choice.

How to Substitute: A pinch of dried thyme is enough to add your desired flavor.

Suggested Dishes:

• Cheese Dip
• Pork Chops

3. Coriander Seeds

Coriander seeds have an earthy and nutty flavor similar to cumin seeds. If your dish requires you to add cumin and unfortunately you don’t. You can use coriander seeds instead.

How to Substitute: Equal parts of cumin seeds for equal parts of coriander seeds

Suggested Dishes:

• Pickled Vegetables
• Beef and Noodle Soup

Bottom Line

No cumin seeds? Try any of our mentioned substitutes for a final tasty boost to your meal.

This is by us, kitchen witches!

We hope your search for a cumin seed alternative has been completed with this guide.

What spice or herb do you plan to use for your food?

Share with us your thoughts or other substitutes for cumin seeds.

Happy Cooking, Gourmets!

Also, don’t forget to pin/bookmark and visit our blog for more interesting but original information.